CASE REPORT  
Niger J Paed 2013; 40 (4): 428 – 430  
Audu LI  
Prune belly syndrome in a set of  
twins, a family tragedy: Case report  
Mairami AB  
Mukhtar-Yola M  
Otuneye AT  
Tahir LM  
Papka NY  
Mshelia LJ  
Maitala H  
Igoche MI  
Anyanwu PA  
Jawa ZM  
DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.4314/njp.v40i4,17  
Accepted: 4th May 2013  
Abstract We report prune belly  
syndrome, a rare congenital mal-  
formation, in a set of twins deliv-  
ered to a young couple with a  
history of three previous first tri-  
mester spontaneous abortions,  
discordant HIV seropositivity and  
antenatal ultrasound report that  
indicated renal abnormalities in  
only one of the twins. The  
challenges of management are  
discussed.  
(
)
Audu LI,  
Mairami AB, Mukhtar-Yola M,  
Otuneye A T, Tahir LM, Papka NY,  
Mshelia LJ, Maitala H, Igoche MI,  
Anyanwu PA, Jawa ZM  
Department of Paediatrics,  
National Hospital Abuja  
Keywords: Prune Belly  
Syndrome, Twins, Nigeria,  
Management challenges  
Email: drauduli@yahoo.com  
Introduction  
Case Report  
Prune Belly Syndrome (PBS), a rare congenital malfor-  
mation presenting at birth with a triad of abdominal  
muscle deficiency, urinary tract abnormalities and cryp-  
This set of male twin babies were born at the National  
Hospital Abuja, via elective caesarean section at a gesta-  
tional age of 34 weeks. The initial part of her antenatal  
care was at a private hospital from where she was re-  
ferred to the National Hospital to access care for retrovi-  
ral infection. Her last CD4 count done shortly before  
1
torchidism has rarely been reported in multiple gesta-  
tions. The incidence varies from 1:35,000-1:50,000 live  
births and only 4% of cases are products of twin preg-  
nancies. The first documented case occurring in both  
live born monozygotic twins was in 2000 by Balaji et  
3
delivery was 228 cells/mm . Although there was no fam-  
ily history of congenital malformations, the index preg-  
nancy was preceded by three successive spontaneous  
first trimester abortions.  
2
al. Although a few cases of PBS have been reported  
3
,4,5,6  
our report is the first documented  
from Nigeria,  
occurrence of PBS in twin gestation in Nigeria. Antena-  
tal diagnosis in developing countries may be limited by  
unavailability of radiologic facilities and expertise, often  
compounded by failure of pregnant mothers to attend  
antenatal clinics, while financial constraints affect the  
extent to which postnatal evaluation can be conducted.  
The success of surgical treatment (abdominoplasty, bi-  
lateral orchiopexy and urinary tract reconstruction) in  
carefully selected patients is a function of prompt and  
comprehensive diagnostic work up.  
During the course of her antenatal visits at the National  
Hospital Abuja, she had three obstetric ultrasound scans  
and each reported the presence of renal malformations in  
one fetus while the second fetus was consistently, re-  
portedly normal. Findings in both babies at birth in-  
cluded lax anterior abdominal wall, bilateral flank full-  
ness, palpable kidneys and undescended testes on the  
basis of which a diagnosis of PBS was made (figure 1).  
Apart from talipes equino varus deformity in the first  
twin, other findings were essentially normal. They had  
good Apgar scores, weighed 2.93kg and 3.07 kg respec-  
tively at birth and were not in respiratory distress.  
7
This communication highlights the diagnostic and man-  
agement challenges encountered in a set of twins with  
Prune Belly Syndrome delivered at the National Hospi-  
tal Abuja.  
The initial serum electrolytes (E), urea (U) and  
creatinine (Cr) revealed elevated potassium and  
creatinine levels. Abdominopelvic ultrasound revealed  
bilateral hydronephrosis with completely thinned out  
4
29  
9
renal parenchyma. Serial E, U, Cr showed deteriorating  
renal function in both twins and intravenous urogram  
normal intrauterine life. Ramasamy et al while studying  
11 cases of familial PBS had suggested a sex linked  
autosomal pattern of inheritance. It may be tempting to  
speculate familial PBS in our patients, but we do not  
have sufficient information about the aborted fetuses to  
support this speculation.  
(
IVU) was therefore considered unsafe. A radionuclide  
renogram was conducted and this showed poorly func-  
tioning kidneys with bilateral vesico-ureteric reflux in  
both twins.  
Fig 1: A set of male twins with Prune Belly Syndrome  
Although our patients did not die in the neonatal period,  
their clinical presentation at birth and the progressive  
renal functional deter1i0oration put them in the most se-  
vere category of PBS.  
There have been few reports of PBS in Nigeria. Okeniyi  
3
et al postulated reasons for the rarity and these include:  
low awareness, missed diagnosis at maternity centers  
and high rate of deliveries outside the health institutions2.  
Twinning is said to be associated with PBS. Balaji et al  
first reported concordant PBS in a set of monozygotic  
twins. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first re-  
port of PBS in concordant twins from Nigeria. On the  
other hand, familial PBS is rarer with less than 20 cases  
reported worldwide. The case reported from UBTH in  
Nigeria occurred in a child with a5n affected older sibling  
suggesting a familial occurrence.  
The discoloration on one of the twins resulted from reflection  
of light from the overhead radiant warmer  
The limitation of obstetric ultrasonography in the detec-  
tion of congenital malformations which may be an indi-  
cation of the experience of the ultrasonographer was  
amply demonstrated in our patients. Although it is a  
significant improvement over previous reports where  
babies were only discovered at delivery to be abnormal,  
the non-specificity and inadequacy of the ultrasound  
reports precluded any form of emergency obstetric inter-  
vention (such as bilateral nephrostomy) and appropriate  
preparation for neonatal care.  
They received intravenous fluids, antibiotics and Nevi-  
rapine (Anti Retroviral Viral prophylaxis). Bilateral  
loop ureterostomy for urinary diversion was done on the  
fifth day of life following which there was some im-  
provement in renal function.  
Additional treatment included top-up blood transfusions  
done on two occasions. The first twin also developed  
scrotal swelling due to hypoproteinemia during the sec-  
ond week of life that resolved gradually with the intro-  
duction of enteral feeds after an initial infusion of albu-  
min. Their subsequent hospital stay was essentially un-  
eventful. The parents were counseled and the mother  
was encouraged to participate in the feeding and general  
care of the babies.  
The presence of the classical triad of lax abdominal  
wall, cryptorchidism and enlarged kidneys at birth  
enabled immediate clinical diagnosis. The results of  
serial electrolytes, urea and creatinine showed progres-  
sive deterioration in renal function with some improve-  
ment when ureterostomy was done. Although it was  
contraindicated to carry out intravenous urography, we  
had the option of radionuclide renal scan which demon-  
strated bilateral poor renal function in both babies. It  
was therefore possible to prognosticate and appropri-  
ately counsel the parents.  
Both babies were discharged home at the age of 24 days  
to be followed up in the clinic. However, the first twin  
died from suspected aspiration of feeds at home three  
days after discharge while the second twin died from a  
respiratory infection at the age of three months.  
Prognosis for patients with PBS usually depends on the  
state of the urinary tract at birth as well as the degree of  
pulmonary hypoplasia. In those with the severe form of  
disease1,0death occurs in utero or in the early neonatal  
period. Our patients presented with evidence to sug-  
gest abnormal urinary system at birth. While the first  
twin died in the late neonatal period, the second twin  
died in the immediate post neonatal period.  
Discussion  
The exact aetiology of PBS is unclear, however postula-  
tions on the pathogenesis of this congenital disorder  
include prostatic hypoplasia resulting in functional ure-  
thral obstru8 ction or a basic defect of the embryonic  
1
mesoderm. Although sex-influenced mode of inheri-  
tance has also been postulated because of the male pre-  
ponderance of the disease, this may be linked with the  
theory of prostatic deficiency. Our patients were both  
males confirming the predominant occurrence of PBS in  
males. The previous history of recurrent spontaneous  
first trimester abortions may have resulted from severe  
congenital malformations that were not compatible with  
The inaccurate prenatal report constituted an ethical  
issue and also compounded parental counseling. Addi-  
tionally, the long-term benefit of surgical urinary diver-  
sion despite apparent poor prognosis was difficult to  
justify.  
4
30  
This young couple who had lost three previous pregnan-  
cies and tested positive for HIV in the index pregnancy,  
had hoped that they would be home with one normal  
baby based on the antenatal ultrasound reports. This was  
one tragedy too many.  
Covering Letter: The undersigned authors certify that  
the article is original, is not under any consideration by  
any other journal and has not been previously published.  
Authors’ contribution  
Audu LI, Mairami AB: Clinical management of babies  
and preparation of manuscript  
Mukhtar-Yola M, Otuneye AT, Tahir LM, Papka NY,  
Mshelia LJ, Maitala H, Clinical management of babies  
Igoche MI, Anyanwu PA: Carried out ureterostomy on  
the babies  
Conclusion  
Accurate antenatal diagnosis of PBS remains a challenge  
in developing countries. Clinical diagnosis at birth as  
well as prompt laboratory and radiologic evaluation will  
enable appropriate plan for management and  
prognostication.  
Jawa ZM: Performed radionuclide assessment on babies  
Conflict of interest: None  
Funding: None  
References  
1
.
Moerman P, Fryns JP, Goddeeris  
P, Lauweryns JM. Pathogenesis of  
the prune-belly syndrome: a func-  
tional urethral obstruction caused  
by prostatic hypoplasia. Paediat-  
rics. 1984 Apr;73 (4): 470-5.  
Balaji K, Patil A, Townes P, Pri-  
mack W, Skare J. Concordant  
prune belly syndrome in monozy-  
gotic twins. Urology 2000;55:949.  
Okeniyi JAO, Ogunlesi TA,  
5. Ibadin MO, Ademola AA,  
8. Stephens FD, Gupta D. Pathogene-  
sis of the prune belly syndrome. J  
Urol. 1994 Dec; 152 (6 Pt 2): 2328  
-31.  
9. Ramasamy R, Haviland M,  
Woodard JR, Barone JG. Patterns  
of inheritance in familial prune  
belly syndrome. Urology 2005;  
65:1227.  
10. Woodhouse CRJ, Ransley PG,  
Innes-Williams D. Prune belly  
syndrome- report of 47 cases. Arch  
Dis Child 1982; 57:856-859.  
11. Mehta BJ, Patel SV, Bansal A,  
Barot B, Nair SV, Damor PB, Shah  
KD. Prune Belly Syndrome. Guja-  
rat Med J 2010 Feb; 65(1):71-72.  
Ofoewe GE. Familial Prune  
Belly Syndrome in a Nigerian  
Family. Saudi J Kidney Dis  
Transpl 2012; 23 (2): 338-342.  
6. Adekanmbi A.F, Fetuga M.B,  
Ogunlesi T.A, Ogundeyi M.M,  
Gbadebo F, Oyinlade A. Prune  
Belly Syndrome in Sagamu:  
Report of Three cases with Typi-  
cal and Atypical Features. Niger  
J Paediatr 2006; 33:(1)22-25.  
7. Denes FT, Arap MA, Giron AM,  
Silva FA, Arap S. Comprehen-  
sive surgical treatment of prune  
belly syndrome; 17 years’ ex-  
perience with 32 patients. Urol-  
ogy 2004 Oct; 64(4): 789-93.  
2
3
.
.
Dedeke IOF, Oyelami OA,  
Oyedeji GA. Prune Belly Syn-  
drome in a Nigerian child. Internet  
J Pediatr Neonatol 2005;5:2.  
Adeyokunnu AA, Familusi JB.  
Prune belly syndrome in two sib-  
lings and a first cousin, possible  
genetic implications. Am J Dis  
Child 1982; 136: 23-25.  
4
.